Is It Real or Luck? Standard Errors, t-stats, and p-values

Learn what standard error, confidence intervals, t-statistics, and p-values do and do not prove, in plain English.

Category: Statistics

In plain English

Imagine you flip a coin 10 times and get 6 heads. Is the coin rigged, or did you just get lucky? Statistics is the toolkit for answering 'is this real, or could it be luck?' When SurgeFlow measures something, like how much a group of stocks beat another group, the number is never perfectly clean. These tools tell you how much to trust it. They do not tell you the truth for certain. They tell you how surprised you should be if the result were really just chance.

What it measures

Four words show up again and again, and each answers a slightly different question. Together they ask: if there were truly no effect at all, how likely is the result we saw? A small worked example: suppose a strategy earned an average of 0.4% per month, and the standard error of that average is 0.1%. The t-statistic is 0.4 divided by 0.1, which equals 4. A t-stat of 4 is large, so a p-value would be tiny. That is a result chance struggles to explain. A t-stat near 1 would not be. - Standard error: how much an average would wobble if you re-ran the measurement. Smaller means steadier. - Confidence interval: a range the true value plausibly sits in, e.g. '0.4% give or take 0.2%, so 0.2% to 0.6%'. - t-statistic: the result divided by its standard error. Bigger (further from 0) means harder to dismiss as luck. Roughly, a t-stat above ~2 is the common rule-of-thumb threshold. - p-value: the chance of seeing a result this big if the real effect were zero. Small p (e.g. 0.01) means 'luck alone rarely does this'.

How SurgeFlow uses it

These statistics underpin the Factors tab (/factors). A 'factor' is a rule that sorts stocks (for example, cheap versus expensive), and SurgeFlow tracks the return gap, called the spread, between the two groups over time. For each factor it shows a T-stat next to that spread, which is the average gap divided by its standard error. The bigger the T-stat, the less likely the gap is just noise. SurgeFlow reports HAC t-stats where the data warrant it (HAC means Heteroskedasticity- and Autocorrelation-Consistent, also called Newey-West). In plain terms, daily returns are jumpy and tend to echo each other day to day, which can make a result look stronger than it is. The HAC correction widens the error bars to account for that, giving a more conservative, often smaller t-stat. - Spread: the return of the 'top' group minus the 'bottom' group of a factor. - T-stat shown on /factors: average spread divided by its standard error. - HAC / Newey-West: an adjustment that stops jumpy, self-correlated data from faking strength. - Joint tests across many factors at once (such as a GRS-style test) guard against cherry-picking one lucky factor; this is a planned addition as the sample history matures.

How to read it on the site

Open the Factors tab (/factors) and look at the T-stat column next to each factor's spread. As a rough guide, a HAC t-stat comfortably above 2 means the historical gap is unlikely to be pure chance; a t-stat near or below 1 means it could easily be luck and deserves little weight. Always read it alongside the actual return size, not on its own. A factor can be 'statistically real' yet tiny, or large in size but too noisy to trust. Treat the t-stat as a confidence dial, not a buy or sell button.

What it cannot tell you

A small p-value or a big t-stat is easy to misread, so be careful. These numbers describe the past data SurgeFlow measured; they are not forecasts, and a real-looking edge can fade once everyone knows it. None of this proves cause: a factor can line up with returns by coincidence (correlation is not causation). And the more rules you test, the more likely one looks 'significant' by pure luck, which is called multiple testing or p-hacking, like flipping 100 coins and bragging about the one that hit 9 heads. - Statistical significance is not economic significance: 'real' does not mean 'big enough to matter'. - Significant in history does not mean it will repeat in the future. - Correlation found here is not proof of cause. - Test enough factors and some will look great by chance; one impressive t-stat in isolation is weak evidence. - These are research and education tools. SurgeFlow gives no investment advice.