Gross vs Net Returns: Why Costs Decide Winners

Learn the difference between a strategy's return before and after trading costs, and why the gap can turn a "winner" into a loser.

Category: Start Here

In plain English

Imagine you buy and sell things to make money, but every time you trade, someone takes a small slice. Gross return is your profit before that slice is taken. Net return is what is actually left in your pocket after all the slices. The difference between the two is easy to ignore on paper, but it is the number that really matters.

What it measures

Gross return measures price gains alone, as if trading were free. Net return subtracts the real costs of trading: broker fees, the bid-ask spread (the small gap between the price to buy and the price to sell), and slippage (the price moving against you between deciding and actually trading). A strategy that trades a lot pays these costs over and over, so the gap grows with activity. - Gross return: +10% (price moved up, costs ignored) - Costs: 10 trades x 0.2% each = about 2% lost - Net return: +10% - 2% = +8% (what you really keep) - A strategy showing +1% gross but 2% costs is actually -1% net: a loser

How SurgeFlow uses it

SurgeFlow's Backtesting tab does not report gross-only results. When it simulates a strategy over history, it subtracts a transaction-cost assumption measured in basis points (bps), where 1 bp = 0.01%. These cost rates are set per market, because trading in, say, the US is cheaper than in some smaller markets. The reported backtest performance is therefore a net-of-cost estimate, not a frictionless fantasy.

How to read it on the site

Open the Backtesting tab and find the Test Assumptions panel. It spells out the cost model used, including the per-market bps charged on each trade, so you can see exactly what was deducted. When you compare two strategies, the one with the higher headline number is not automatically better. Check how much each trades and how its costs were modelled before drawing any conclusion. - Backtesting tab: shows the performance after costs are removed - Test Assumptions panel: lists the per-market cost rates in bps - Higher trading frequency means a bigger gross-to-net gap - Always read the assumptions before comparing two results

What it cannot tell you

The net return in a backtest is only as honest as its cost assumption, and a fixed bps figure is a simplification. Real-world costs vary by trade size, market stress, and how easy a stock is to buy or sell; large or thinly-traded orders can cost far more than the model assumes. A backtest is a description of the past, not a forecast, and past performance is never a guarantee of future results. SurgeFlow is research and education, not investment advice. - Real costs can be higher than a flat bps estimate - Big or illiquid trades face extra slippage not always modelled - Past net returns do not predict future net returns - This is education, not a buy or sell signal